Shopping for a new car this month? The cheapest average payment on the lot belongs to the hybrids. Experian puts the average new hybrid loan at $646 a month. Gasoline vehicles average $721.
Seventy-five dollars a month. Nine hundred a year. Now here’s the catch: nobody is going to hand you that $75.
Experian’s second-quarter numbers show buyers moving. Hybrids took 16.80% of new-vehicle financing, up from 12.99% a year earlier. EVs went the other way, down to 8.15% from 9.21%. The federal EV tax credit expired last year, and buyers didn’t sit around waiting for Washington to replace it. They walked over to the hybrid row and kept their own money. Melinda Zabritski, who runs automotive financial insights at Experian, said hybrids “seemingly have become a more attractive option for consumers, particularly for those looking to save some money at the pump.”
Here’s what an average payment is not. It’s not a price on one car. Experian is stacking every financed hybrid against every financed gas vehicle, and the gas column has to carry the pickups and the three-row SUVs. The $75 gap is mostly a story about which cars people chose, not a hybrid discount waiting at the finance desk.
The savings that are real happen at the pump, and you can check them yourself in two minutes.
Regular gas averaged $4.157 a gallon for the week of September 7, according to the Energy Information Administration. That’s 96.5 cents higher than the same week last year. Drive 12,000 miles a year in a 30 mpg car and you burn 400 gallons, about $1,663. Do it at 45 mpg and you burn 267 gallons, about $1,109. Call it $554 a year, or $46 a month.
Average new loan: $43,610 at 6.35%. Over 72 months that’s roughly $730 a month, and one percentage point of rate is worth about $21 of it.
That last number matters more than the badge. Fuel type is a choice you make once. The rate is a choice you make with a phone call, and most people never make it. Twenty-one dollars a month on the average new loan is about $1,500 over six years, for the work of getting one more quote.
So do this in order.
Price both versions of the same car, hybrid trim and gas trim, out the door. Take the price difference and divide it by your monthly fuel savings. If the hybrid runs $2,000 more and saves you $46 a month, you break even in about 43 months. Drive a lot and that’s an easy yes. Drive 6,000 miles a year and the pump savings will never catch the sticker.
Then get your financing before you walk in. Pull a quote from a credit union and one from an online lender, run the real payment through our loan calculator, and compare what’s on offer on our best loans page. Don’t let the finance desk stretch the term to make a hybrid look affordable, because the longer loan costs more even when the rate looks better.
One more line for the curious. Leases run the same way: hybrids average $566 a month, gas $602, EVs $641. And the used market is still the expensive room, at an average 11.19% against 6.35% on new.
How Candid Yak makes money. Some of the products we write about pay us if you apply or sign up through our links. That never changes our verdict, our rankings, or the numbers in this article. We call a bad deal a bad deal whether it pays us or not. Some brands shown in our comparison tools are placeholder examples while we finalize partner agreements, and we label them as such.